Are Employee Performance Reviews Effective?

The Annual Employee Performance Review should beBenefits Package becomes less the focus, as does
a thing of the past. Performances should be gaugedpay scale for that matter. Let's not, however, diminish
by comparing the Actual and Targeted Budgets forthe fact that Benefits are critically important to retaining
Company Divisions, and how employees in thoseand keeping talent, but if your Compensation Structure
business units contributed or hindered the Company'sis designed as previously indicated, the entrepreneur
Budget. As a Business Consultant and Entrepreneurwill find employees who are willing to defray the cost
with over 20 years experience working with differentof Benefit Packages with the Company via cost
corporate cultures, I think an Employee's Performancesharing, HSAs, etc.
should be examined as it contributes to the company'sA Benefits Package should be comprehensive in its
bottom-line profits. Shouldn't Performance Systems beoffering, i.e. Health, Disability, Life Insurance and a
about a Company's Profitability and an Individual'sRetirement Investment Vehicle, but if designed as part
Growth? Of course it should be. Performanceof a whole, a progressive Compensation Package
Reviews ought to be part of a Company'swhose sum of the parts is very competitive in
Compensation Structure to achieve betterattracting and retaining top talent, then it becomes
subordinate-manager relationships andmore a question of structure than importance. The
common-goal-teamwork toward achieving abest advice I can give to companies, as a Business
Company's Strategic Goals.Consultant with a Financial Planning background
Let's take this a step further to see its real benefit.working with small businesses: hire a Financial Planning
Doesn't Performance have a lot to do with aExpert who specializes in designing and implementing
company's Compensation Strategy, contributingBenefits Packages which aren't seen as the focal
significantly to the bottom line? Well, I say, everything!point of a Compensation Package but a part of. If
Fostering an atmosphere and structure of bilateraldesigned and packaged properly, a Benefits Program
relationships between managers and team membersdoes not necessarily have to drain cash flow, and for
should be built into a Company's Compensation Plan,minimum financial contribution on the employee's end, it
as that achieves:can still be an attractive incentivized component of the
1. Common goals toward achieving company success.overall Compensation Package.
2. Higher individual productivityI highly recommend using a Financial Services
3. Accountability between team members andCompany to package the entire Benefits Plan as the
management, as well as, upper management and thebundling will save you significant dollars, and the
executive level.employee will have a cohesive, very comprehensive
4. Happier employees work harder and smarterplan which offers a singular, un-complicated customer
5. Retain highly valuable, well trained, experiencedsupport system. It is vitally important a Company utilize
employees as this system fosters trust, improvement,the expertise of a Benefits Expert to find a Financial
loyalty and advancement.Services Company which offers substantial-breath of
6. Achieves the same objectives as do Stock Optioninvestment options and benefits to satisfy a wide
Plans. As people improve and add to a Company'srange of employees, managers and executives. A
success, the reward of stock appreciation is thewell-crafted Benefits Package should pay for itself and
financial payoff, more so than pay raises.not be a burden on Company Cash Flow.
However, the question to be asked is where doI also make the contention that Pay Scale is not very
Benefits fit into Compensation Planning for new andimportant in the overall scheme of things as long as
growing small companies? Well, I argue that it is morepay is not the focal point but a part of a Progressive,
a part of employee morale than it is a part of theIncentivized, Comprehensive, Competitive, Proactive
compensation package. Ok, so you maybe scratchingbased Compensation Plan. Highly talented and
your head on this one as Benefits are often viewedexperienced people will work for less pay than the
as an integral component of a compensation package.market offers if a Company offers a Compensation
Where most companies dangle the Benefits Package,Package as prescribed in this article. The Performance
which in turn can be very expensive to the company,Preview plays into this fact that a fair employee and
as a carrot to attract and retain talent, the mostexecutive evaluation and education system considers
progressive companies understand its importance inCompensation Structures and Benefits, and if done
the grand scheme of things. Young, growingproperly, will save the company tons on their
companies have a hard time affording comprehensiveCompensation Program yet still promoting higher levels
Benefits Packages and find them to be a big strain onof profitability. It is necessary to have a good balance
cash flow. However, if your Compensation Packagebetween the two areas to attract and retain talent at
includes Stock Options, Tax Preferencea level a company can afford and still have plenty of
Compensation, Key Person Protection and aroom to grow.
Proactive-based Performance System, then the